CHERRY-O CREAM CHEESE PIE

016 (3)

I found this vintage wooden box at a local estate sale.  Although I liked the box enough by itself, its contents were even more interesting to me:

013

It was a collection of handwritten recipe cards and yellowed recipe clippings.  I’ve been asking for my Mom’s recipe collection since she passed away last year, but my Dad is not quite ready to part with it.  There is something about her recipes–in her distinctive cramped hand, with her personal notes about the recipes (Delish! Use nonfat milk!)–that provides a glimpse of her personality.  They tell a story about her–the way she loved to entertain, the way she was always watching her weight, the friends who shared their recipes and good times with her.  In an article by Kate Murphy published recently in the New York Times, entitled “Between the Recipes, Scribbles Speak Volumes,” the author mused that cookbooks are “possibly the most annotated form of literature.”  As she describes, “[w]hether practical, historical, sentimental or smudged with chocolate ganache, marginalia in cookbooks can tell the story of a life and be a lasting memorial to the scribbler.”  I want my Mom’s recipes, not so much to make them, but to channel my Mom.  A stranger’s will have to do for now.

My personal recipe collection is more OCD than my Mom’s or this woman’s.  Years ago I started printing my recipes on the fancy papers that started showing up in stationery stores.  It was fun to fit the papers to the recipes.  There are no handwritten notes on my recipes, but my cookbook is pretty to flip through.  Here’s a few examples:

018 (2)

019 (2)

As I was going through the recipes in the old box, I came across this one for Cherry-O Cream Cheese Pie:

photo2

photo

My Mom used to make this pie all the time.  This clipping must date back to the 1960s.  Looking around the interwebs, I see that this recipe is still popular today.

Today happens to be George Washington‘s birthday.  The Father of Our Country, he is consistently ranked among the top three presidents of the United States (no idea who the other two are).  In 1968 Congress passed the “Monday Holiday Law” to “provide uniform annual observances of certain legal public holidays on Mondays.”  By creating more 3-day weekends, Congress hoped to “bring substantial benefits to both the spiritual and economic life of the Nation.”  So today, instead of celebrating Washington’s birthday on February 22, his actual birthday, we celebrate it as a federal holiday, unofficially known as President’s Day, on the third Monday in February.  Interestingly, this guarantees that his birthday will never be celebrated on his actual birthday, because the third Monday in February can never fall any later than February 21.  (In other words, the latest the first Monday could be is the 7th, which would mean that the third Monday would be the 21st.)  I think George gets ripped off having to share his birthday on a random date with every other president — like having a birthday in December and getting combined birthday and Christmas presents.  On the other hand, I think the idea of moving a birthday around can be good.  For example, I might have liked to have moved my kids’ birthdays to the summer, when you don’t have to send cupcakes to school, and don’t really even have to have a party because no one is around.

Anyway, to many kids, George Washington is best remembered for chopping down a cherry tree.  As the fabricated story goes, little George used his hatchet to chop down his father’s cherry tree.  When his angry father asked who did it, George said, “I cannot tell a lie — I chopped down the cherry tree.”  His father was supposedly so pleased that George told the truth, that he considered it payment for the tree.  I don’t know about you, but lying always worked better for me.

Inspired by the decades-old clipping in the recipe box, memories of Mom, and in celebration of George Washington’s birthday, I made a Cherry-O Cream Cheese Pie.  It’s quick, it’s easy, and it’s pretty darn tasty.

Print
Ingredients
  • 9-inch prepared graham cracker crumb crust*
  • 8-ounce package cream cheese, softened
  • 14-ounce can sweetened condensed milk
  • ⅓ cup lemon juice
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla
  • 1 lb. 6.oz. can prepared cherry pie filling
Instructions
  1. Place cream cheese in a medium bowl and using an electric mixer, beat until fluffy. Gradually add sweetened condensed milk, mixing until well blended. Mix in lemon juice and vanilla. Pour into prepared crust. Chill 2 to 3 hours before covering top of pie with cherry pie filling.
  2. *To make your own graham cracker crust: Preheat oven to 375 degrees. In a small bowl, mix together 1-1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs (approximately 12 whole graham crackers), 6 tablespoons melted butter, and ⅓ cup sugar. Press into a 9-inch pie plate using the back of a spoon, being sure to press it up the sides of the pan. Bake for 8-10 minutes, until edges are lightly browned. Cool completely before filling.

004 (6)

Baked graham cracker crust, waiting for its filling
021
Happy 281st birthday George Washington!
001 (9)
I cannot tell a lie — this pie is really good

11 thoughts on “CHERRY-O CREAM CHEESE PIE

  1. I have made this pie all my married life – 37 years and we love it. I have been typing all my recipes into a binder on templates I created and one part of the template is reserved for the “history” of the recipe. I only have one of my Mother’s handwriten recipes, but I am making a section in the binder to display all the handwritten recipes I have from long-gone relatives. I too, love to read what I have written over the years in the margins. Thanks for the original pie ad – it is wonderful!

    • I never thought to include the “history” on the recipes in my binder — what a great idea! Glad you enjoyed the ad. I got such a kick out of it when I found it.

  2. I’m so sorry that you lost your mom. I lost mine when I was 21 and ever since that time whenever I have the great luck of running across her handwriting I feel so connected to her. You need to be sure and write on your recipes so your children will feel the same just in case they lose you someday in the very distant future. Of course they are lucky they have your wonderful blog posts. I’ve never had this pie but I can’t wait to give it a try sometime.

  3. I am a thrift store/garage sale whore – so I know what you mean. At once garage sale I came across a tattered binder. Inside were cut up recipes from magazines, the local paper, etc.

    On the side this woman wrote handwritten notes – “Don’t make again – not worth it!” “Next time, add more salt.” I brought this up to the woman who was hosting the garage sale, and told her “you must not have seen that this was in the stuff you wanted to sell.” She said “you can have it for a quarter!” It now rests with the rest of my cookbooks, and I smile knowing that her recipe legacy continues, even if not in her own family.

    That’s why I love blogging so much – just think that my future grandchildren (my daughters just about to turn 21 – so FUTURE!) get to read my daily thoughts just thrills me to pieces.

    • What a great story! It is amazing to me that people would not see the value in their mothers’ or grandmothers’ recipes — it’s such a part of a person’s heritage. And now to check our your blog . . . . 🙂

  4. I love this pie! My Mom made it all the time before my Dad became diabetic. Hmmm. Anyway, there was a similar Key Lime version that is also yummy.

I'd love to hear from you!